Cookies and consent — UK GDPR and PECR
Cookie consent is where UK GDPR meets PECR. A cookie banner with a clear accept button but a buried reject option does not provide valid consent. The ICO has been increasingly active on cookie enforcement, and the pattern of what it challenges is instructive for any organisation running a website.
Two overlapping regimes
Cookie use is governed by the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations 2003 (PECR) and UK GDPR simultaneously. PECR requires consent before non-essential cookies are set. UK GDPR provides the standard for what valid consent means. Both apply — a cookie consent mechanism must comply with both.
Strictly necessary cookies
PECR provides an exemption for cookies strictly necessary to provide a service explicitly requested by the user. Session cookies keeping a user logged in and shopping cart cookies are typically strictly necessary. Analytics and advertising cookies are not — they serve the organisation’s purposes, not the user’s requested service, and require consent.
What valid consent looks like
PECR consent must meet the UK GDPR standard — freely given, specific, informed, and unambiguous. Pre-ticked boxes are not valid. Cookie walls that deny access without accepting all cookies are not considered freely given consent. A compliant mechanism includes separate opt-in options per category, an equivalent reject-all option, and the ability to withdraw consent as easily as it was given.
ICO enforcement
The ICO has issued enforcement notices for dark patterns — designs making acceptance easier than rejection, or that bury the reject option. Organisations whose cookie banners require more steps to reject than to accept are at risk. The ICO has indicated that equivalent prominence between accept and reject pathways is expected, and this is a strong factor in its enforcement decisions.
Analytics cookies
Analytics cookies, including Google Analytics, are not strictly necessary and require PECR consent before being set. The fact that data may later be anonymised does not remove the consent requirement — the cookie is set before any anonymisation occurs. Consent must be obtained before the analytics cookie fires.